“Natural sweeteners are healthier than artificial sweeteners.”
No evidence shows that natural sweeteners are healthier than artificial ones; honey, maple syrup and agave still count as added sugar.
Choose a sweetener based on taste, amount and your goals. Natural sweeteners are not a healthier pick by default, and approved artificial ones are not something to fear.
Use the sweetener you prefer in a reasonable amount and focus more on total added sugar than on marketing labels.
Safety note: People with phenylketonuria (PKU) need to avoid or restrict aspartame according to their care plan.
Talk to a healthcare professional if: you have PKU, or you need individual help managing your blood sugar and choosing sweeteners.
Moderate confidence because caloric natural sweeteners such as honey and maple syrup still count as added sugar, and approved low-calorie sweeteners are considered safe within established limits. No study shows a sweetener is healthier because it is natural, and honey trials show only mixed, low-certainty changes in risk markers.
No evidence shows that natural sweeteners are healthier than artificial ones; honey, maple syrup and agave still count as added sugar. Approved low-calorie sweeteners, including plant-based ones, can help cut sugar and calories.
Different sweeteners serve different purposes. A natural label does not prove greater safety, and an artificial label does not prove harm.
A low-calorie sweetener may be more useful for reducing sugar, while a caloric sweetener may be chosen for taste. Neither choice determines the quality of the whole diet.
Can different sweeteners serve different goals?
Yes. Either type can fit. Low-calorie sweeteners may help reduce added sugar, and small amounts of caloric sweeteners can make nutritious foods more enjoyable.
- US Food and Drug Administration. High-Intensity Sweeteners. May 19, 2014; accessed October 1, 2026
- Ahmed A, Tul-Noor Z, Lee D, et al. Effect of honey on cardiometabolic risk factors: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Nutrition Reviews. 2023;81(7):758-774; online 2022. DOI: 10.1093/nutrit/nuac086