How we rate a claim.
Every claim gets a verdict and a confidence level. Here’s exactly what each one means.
From true to false
When there’s no single answer
The honest answer changes based on your situation, dose, or goals. There isn’t one verdict that fits everyone.
The research so far is too thin, too mixed, or too early to call. We’ll update this as better evidence comes in.
Evidence confidence
Separate from the verdict itself: how solid is the research behind it?
Multiple high-quality studies (large RCTs, meta-analyses) point the same direction, and the result has held up across independent research groups.
Decent evidence exists, but it’s a smaller body of research, mixed study quality, or not yet replicated as widely as we’d like.
Early, small, or mostly indirect (animal or mechanistic) evidence. Promising, but treat the verdict as a current best guess rather than a settled answer.
The available studies disagree with each other, or there simply isn’t enough research yet to say much with confidence.
How we review a claim
Every card starts with a claim people actually make. We look for the best human research first: systematic reviews, meta-analyses and large controlled trials, then smaller studies, and early or lab-based work only where nothing stronger exists. Each source on a card links to the original paper or report, so you can read it yourself.
We pick the verdict by asking whether the claim, as people state it, matches what that research shows. We set the evidence confidence by how strong and consistent the research is. Every card shows the date it was last reviewed.
We update these cards as new research comes out. When the evidence changes, our verdicts change too. If you think we got one wrong, use “Suggest a correction” at the bottom of any card.